Cancellation Playbook: Requests, Retention, Failed Payments, Rescues, Downgrades, and Offboarding

This playbook covers every cancellation path: Grow and Max cancel requests, Coaching and Starter cancels, failed payments, cancel rescues, downgrades to New Starter, and final offboarding (Google Ads, Google Analytics, Google Business Profile, and the sub-account).

Golden rule: no matter how the request arrives, update the subscription in Spiffy first so the church does not get rebilled by accident. Spiffy is the source of truth for billing. ChargeDesk is still used for alerts and has the most accurate older payment history.

1. Grow and Max Cancel Requests

If the church is a Coaching or Starter member, skip to section 2.

Update Spiffy first

  1. Open the subscription in Spiffy.
  2. Push the billing date out by three months (use the update/change payment date option). This gives the Retention lead time to reach out.
  3. Click Cancel, then choose End of cycle. The subscription shows as Cancelling and stays active during the retention window.

Identify the entry point

  • Entry A, email request: reply to acknowledge and ask them to complete the Membership Adjustment Form. In Help Scout use the Saved Reply !!Grow Cancel Reply IF No Form.
  • Entry B, adjustment form submission: arrives automatically by email when the member submits the form.
  • Facebook ads (both entry points): the Grow cancel saved replies (!!Grow Cancel Reply IF No Form, Grow Cancel - Form Completed, Team will call, and Grow Cancel Request - Form Reply) tell the church that if they want their Facebook ads paused, they need to pause them themselves in Facebook Ads Manager. Cancelling with us does not stop ads running in their own ad account. Do not remove that paragraph when you send these replies.

Complete the Pre-Cancellation Form (the cancel inspection)

  1. Open the Pre-Cancellation Form in an incognito/private window. Submitting it notifies the Setup team to pause active setup work.
  2. Open three tabs: the Contact record, the Church record, and the church sub-account.
    • Contact: search the customer's name in Smartlists and verify the record.
    • Church: search the contact's Business Name in Churches.
    • Sub-account: search the Business Name in sub-accounts, then check Settings > Users to confirm it is the right church.
  3. Rename the sub-account to Church Name - City - State Abbr. and paste that exact string into the form's "Church Name - City - State" field.
  4. Gather the form data:
    • Customer info: name and email of the person who requested the cancel (add the billing contact's email in notes if different).
    • True start date: review billing history. Migrated accounts can show a "ghost transaction," so use ChargeDesk history and your best judgment.
    • Pricing: confirm the current monthly price.
    • Account Rep: check for an assigned rep on the contact and church. If none, enter N/A.
    • FB Ads: log into business.facebook.com, find the ad account using the Leadsie info on the church profile, and summarize performance.
    • Google Ads: check the sub-account dashboard for Grant reporting. If missing, log into google@churchfuel.com at ads.google.com, find their Grant ID on the Church/Contact record, and compare real leads vs. test leads in their Connections Pipeline.
  5. Submit the form: choose Retain Attempt (unless the church is actually closing), set Failed Payment? to No, and paste any email context into Cancellation Notes.

Retention

About 95% of cancel requests are retainable, so treat every one as a conversation. Submitting the Pre-Cancellation Form puts the church in the Retention Call Sequence and alerts the Retention lead.

  • Retained: the workflow stops, the Setup team is told to resume setup, and the Account Rep lead is told to assign a rep. A Cancel Rescue task may be created (see section 4).
  • Not retainable: the opportunity moves to Not Retainable, which triggers final offboarding (section 6).

2. Coaching and Starter Cancel Requests

  1. Update Spiffy: find the subscription, click Cancel, choose End of cycle, click Cancel Subscription, and confirm it shows Cancelling.
  2. Route through the cancellation automation: send the contact through the designated cancellation automation. Find their current step and check whether they are in a Wait step before changing anything.
  3. Reply by entry point:
    • Entry A, email: acknowledge and ask for feedback with the Saved Reply !!Cancel Confirmation - Coaching or Starter.
    • Entry B, adjustment form: first change the Help Scout ticket's customer to the member's real email (forms arrive via success@, and skipping this causes a reply loop). Then send !!Cancel Confirmation - Coaching or Starter, removing the feedback paragraph if they already answered it on the form.
  4. Remove them from the member adjustment workflow. Starter and Coaching churches never need an opportunity. Open the contact in GoHighLevel, find their step in the member adjustment workflow (usually a Wait step before the opportunity is created), remove them, and confirm they are no longer active. If they are not in that workflow, there is nothing to remove.

Troubleshooting:

  • Opportunity already in Cancellations: remove the contact from the workflow, delete the card, and flag it to the dev team if it keeps happening.
  • Do not use the member adjustment tag or skip-step for Starter or Coaching. Both push the contact toward opportunity creation.
  • Not sure of the church's plan type: stop and verify before cancelling.
  • Workflow not behaving as described: flag it to the dev team with the church, contact, and stuck step.

3. Failed Payment Notifications

  1. Watch for ChargeDesk emails with subjects like Subscription to Grow Retail Monthly Unpaid or Past Due.
  2. Confirm the payment status in Spiffy.
  3. Complete the Pre-Cancellation Form as in section 1 (cancel inspection only) and check the Failed Payment box.
  4. Close the ChargeDesk email.

4. Processing a Cancel Rescue Task

Video: Cancel Rescue walkthrough

  1. Open the task in the Success Inbox to review the rescue details and customer name.
  2. Search Spiffy by customer email (more accurate than name) and open the active or cancelling subscription, not the order.
  3. Click stop the cancellation to resume the subscription. Add one brief log note.
  4. Push the payment date as agreed (for example, skipping July and August means setting it to September 12).
  5. If the price changes, select the matching adjustment subscription plan (for example, $399 to $299) and choose change at the end of cycle to avoid an immediate charge.
  6. Turn off keep discount if old promotions should not carry over.
  7. For temporary pricing (for example, 3 months), use an expiring discount or automatic end date. Do not rely on a future manual task.

Guardrails: only choose adjustment subscription plans, never purchase plans. If the right plan does not exist, create a new adjustment subscription.

5. Downgrading a Customer to New Starter

Video: Downgrade walkthrough. Note the customer's original billing date before you begin.

  1. In Spiffy, open the current subscription, choose Cancel, and select Immediate cancellation (not end of cycle). Add a reason such as "Downgrading to New Starter" and skip automations that are not needed.
  2. Wait until the cancellation fully processes. Starting the new order too early is the most common mistake.
  3. Open New Order, select Starter New, search the customer by name so the profile repopulates, and double-check their info.
  4. Choose the existing payment method. Confirm the promo (typically one free month) is applied and the first cycle shows $0. If the promo is missing, fix it before sending anything. Then send the order confirmation.
  5. Reset the next billing date to match the old cycle. Add a note such as "Updating billing to match previous subscription" and enable the change-payment-date option if required.
  6. Verify the discount and next charge date.
  7. Ask whoever manages the church's Facebook and Google ads to shut paid ads off. Track it as a separate to-do if needed.

If the billing date is very close to today, decide whether to charge now or push the date before finalizing. If the cancellation, new order, or discount fails, escalate to your team lead instead of adjusting charges manually.

6. Final Offboarding

When the opportunity moves to the final cancellation stage, tasks are created for each team:

  • Google Ads team: Google offboarding (below).
  • Facebook team: Facebook Ads offboarding.
  • Success team: in Spiffy, Cancel Immediately, then export contacts and delete the sub-account (below).

Google Ads team offboarding

Video: Google offboarding walkthrough

  1. Confirm the church. Check the Google Unassigned inbox at google@churchfuel.com for the cancellation notification, copy the church name, and verify it matches the account you are about to change. Some cancellations may not appear in Stations yet. Copy the church's Google Grant ID.
  2. Pause our campaigns. In Google Ads, open the church's account, go to Campaigns, and pause every campaign with ChurchFuel or CMU in the name. Leave every other campaign exactly as it is. Those belong to the church.
  3. Unlink the manager account. In the Church Fuel MCC, go to Sub-account Settings, paste the Grant ID (no leading or trailing spaces, or it will not pull up), select the church, click Unlink twice, and confirm it shows as unlinked.
  4. Remove Google Analytics access. Open the church's GA property (check the stream URL if names are similar), go to Admin > Account Access Management, and remove google@churchfuel.com and google@churchmarketinguniversity.com if present. Older accounts may have both.
  5. Remove Google Business Profile access. In the Church Fuel Business Profile Manager, find the church, click See Your Profile, and go to Business Profile Settings > People and Access.
    • If Church Fuel is the only owner: add the church as an owner first, wait for them to accept (GBP invites must be accepted, unlike GA), then remove Church Fuel.
    • If the church or another owner is already listed: remove Church Fuel.
  6. Log completion.

No admins left on the Grant account? Sometimes a cancelled account has no administrators listed and cannot be unlinked or managed. In that case, hide the account in the manager dashboard so it does not skew team stats. If google@churchfuel.com is the only administrator, re-invite the church and encourage them to accept. If space is tight, transfer administration to cancelledchurchfuel@gmail.com (login in the LastPass tied to google@churchfuel.com).

Google offboarding checklist: church verified · Grant ID copied · Church Fuel campaigns paused · other campaigns untouched · MCC unlinked · GA emails removed · GBP access removed (ownership checked first) · completion logged.

Success team: export contacts and delete the sub-account

Be careful. If there are duplicate accounts, make sure you are deleting the correct one.

  1. Export contacts first. Find the church in Steeple, open their Drive folder and GHL link, go to Contacts > three dots > Export, rename the file (for example, Export_Contacts_UnitedInLoveMinistries), and upload it to the church's Drive folder.
  2. Disconnect phone services. In Agency View, go to Settings > Phone Integration, find the sub-account, click the three dots, choose Delete Connection, check the boxes to delete phone numbers, campaigns, and the LeadConnector sub-account, type DELETE, and confirm.
  3. Delete the sub-account. In Agency View, open the sub-account, click Actions > Delete, confirm the prompts, type DELETE, and click Delete Account. If it warns about LeadConnector charges, step 2 was not finished.
  4. The account enters Scheduled for Deletion and is removed after 24 hours. Click Close. Only click "Stop Deletion Operation" if the church changes its mind.

"Disable SaaS mode" warning? (video)

  1. Use the warning prompt to jump to the SaaS settings page.
  2. Check the balance on the Payments tab. It must be $0. If money remains, loop in your supervisor about a refund.
  3. Select the required checkboxes, type CONFIRM, keep the box checked to discontinue SaaS subscriptions, and click Disable SAAS. It can take up to 10 minutes.
  4. Return to the deletion flow and retry.
Did this answer your question? Thanks for the feedback There was a problem submitting your feedback. Please try again later.